CD REVIEW: Winnowing by Bill Mallonee ON SALE – $15.00

Our tears they speak a language that’s uniquely all their own… “Dover Beach (Out in the Cold)” on Winnowing Bill Mallonee & The Darkling Planes

In his splendid theological study of
literature, Frederick Buechner uses as the title a famous linespeak what we feel Buechner.jpg from Shakespeare’s
King Lear: Speak What We Feel, Not What We Ought to Say. In another book —
I mentioned it in my BookNotes list of books about evangelism last month — Buechner’s
title is golden: Tell It Like It Is: The Gospel as Tragedy, Comedy, Fairy Tale.  He explores the characteristics of
these genres and shows how the gospel story itself can be described in these
enduring forms.

Music can help us “speak what we feel”
perhaps more viscerally than novels. 
As I wrote a few days ago about Beverly Lewis’ lovely visit to our store
to speak of her new Amish novel The River (Bethany House; $15.99) which has some dark currents
sweeping through it — I did some free association to link it to Bruce Springsteen’s
anguished song “The River.”  Talk
about speaking what we feel, about redemption somehow coming in the form of
tragedy. “Is a dream a lie if it doesn’t comes true, or is it something worse?”
 Most, but not all, evangelical “Christian
fiction” ties things up pretty nicely, almost unable to host Springsteen’s
question (even though the Bible offers these very sorts of questions!)  Now, I’m glad there is reconciliation
at the end of Lewis’ The River and – spoiler! – that a
modern bit of technology, a pacemaker, is involved.) This is helpful and
inspiring and has its place in one’s reading diet.

But some of our best artists know that
the life is hard, and they help us cope, not with easy answers about the human
condition.  I hardly need to say
it, but that life can be a trail of tears is also true for people of faith (perhaps
especially so for people who have tasted glory and trust God’s promises and
seek real joy.) Need I really say that it is good to be honest about our
doubts? Does your throat not quiver when you sing that line “I’m prone to
wander, Lord, I feel it”?  We don’t
need to valorize or romanticize our pain or foolishness, but it does help to
give voice to our disappointments and troubles, to read books and listen to
artists that walk the dark side of the street, who tell it like it is. They
help us speak not what we “ought” but allow us to berumours of glory memoir.jpgkicking at the darknes.jpg honest about our own fears
and foibles, living as we do in a very broken world.

Brian Walsh has written brilliantly
about this – see his meditation on Bruce Cockburn’s “If I Had a Rocket Launcher”
alongside Psalm 137 in his “Wine Before Breakfast” sermon
.  Perhaps you should read this, first, a short meditation on “Exile, Song, and Rage.” In fact, you could
read his whole book about the prophetic imagination of Cockburn in his
remarkably generative study Kicking at the Darkness: Bruce Cockburn and
the Christian Imagination
(Brazos; $19.00) which I describe in detail,
in a long review, here.

(Big aside: Cockburn’s hefty auto-biography
called Rumours of Glory: A Memoir is coming out from HarperOne
($28.99) the first week of November, and we are taking pre-orders for it, at
20% off. It is sure to be provocative.  There will also be a
commemorative boxed set selling for something like $150.00 which includes all
the songs Bruce mentions in the book, in order, making it a 9 disc soundtrack.  The admittedly pricy boxed set also
includes 16 previously unreleased or rare tracks, a 90 page booklet,
photographs, and a full live concert DVD film during his “Slice O Life” tour.
We’ll have it on sale, too. Send us a note for more info.)

Which brings me to my review of the
harrowing new Bill Mallonee album.  Almost.

Look. I am a huge, huge U2 fan. We carried
Boy and the others when we first
opened in ’82, U2 Songs of Innocence.jpgright, alongside Petra and Amy Grant (and, yes, all of Bruce
Cockburn’s catalog) and we took great joy in introducing many folks to the
boys from Dublin’s early work, and continued to stock all they’ve done. I am
still just blown away by nearly every album – yes, I love Rattle and Hum and yes, I am even moved by some of the hyper-irony
of the electro-weirdness of the Zoo TV
years.  I saw them in Philly during
the Joshua Tree tour when Springsteen
showed up.  And I can’t tell you
how many times I’ve just wept and wept listening to that sad list of names at
the end of “Walk On.”  Haven’t you?
How can you not?

Bwinnowing cover.jpgut I just can’t write about the new
iphone Songs of Innocence release because I am
absorbed in listening over and over to what has become my favorite album of the
year — the incredibly poignant release by the tell it like it is, speak what we
feel, gospel as tragedy Americana/rootsy graveling desert beauty of Bill
Mallonee and his new record Winnowing created with his musical partner and wife, Murriah Rose, singing together as the Darkling Planes.

To distract me from a new U2 album is
quite a feat. And Bill and Mariah do so, mister.

I find it hard to review music. I can explain books, but it is difficult
to capture the aural experience of music, those wailing Rickenbacker guitar
solos, those acoustic chords that bring to mind “All Along the Watchtower” but
aren’t that, that crisp moment when a syllable is hit in falsetto, that whispered
one-two-three-four that launches so quickly the next track, that time when the
loud harmonica merges with the wailing electric guitar, and we don’t quite know
which instrument is which.  

We shouldn’t separate the lyrics from
the music, the timbre of the vocals, the whine, and thebill Mallonee from Winnowing cover.jpg shout and the whispers,
the instruments, the arrangements, the production and engineering;  as we talk about records, we must
remember that the words are part of songs. But how to tell you about it, entice
you to listen? For those that don’t know Bill’s large body of work (50 + albums,
most now available as downloads, some as real CDs, this new one even available in vinyl) I think
the closest comparison to put you in the ball park of the sound is Neil Young,
with moments of Jackson Browne at his best, maybe Tom Petty. (And, oh, how
Bill’s voice ends each time in the chorus of “Got Some Explainin’ to Do” sounds
so much like Neil!) The fuzzy guitars, the distortion that is so gripping, the
high and lonesome beauty given a rock and roll edge. it is very, very moving
for those that appreciate that school of alt-rock.  You can hear tons of his songs for free at his Bandcamp site which I show below.

My own tastes include artists in this
very orbit: Robbie Robertson (and the entire catalog of The Band) and CSNY
and Mark Knopfler, Jackson, and Americana stuff, channeled nowadays by the
likes of The Civil Wars, Mumford & Sons, the Avett Brothers.  And did I mention Rattle and Hum? I appreciate smart, writerly indie bands from The
Head and the Heart to The National, The Airborne Toxic Event, and older school
passionate singer-songwriters like Peirce Pettis, Phil Maideria, country-ish
Buddy Miller. Bill is louder and rougher than Iron and Wine and Fleet Foxes,
but I had to mention them. Can you relate?

bill mallonee hand tattoo.png

If you like rowdy, electric finger-picking,
fuzzy, jangly, Byrds-like soaring guitars, and vocals that can at time nearly
be called Dylan-esque, you should pick up Bill Mallonee. Founder and front man
of the stunning Vigilantes of Love, they were hot in the glory days of the
Athens, Georgia music scene, preaching the gospel in harsh, acoustic songs with
punk energy, allusive, dark lyrics, deep in the club scene that gave us REM
and the Indigo Girls, drawing insight about faith and songwriting from the
likes of the late great Mark Heard.

REM’s Peter Buck co-produced a critically
acclaimed album, Buddy and Julie Miller joined in occasionally, the world-class
alt-country legend Emmy Lou Harris did background vocals. Paste Magazine declared him to be one of the top 50 songwriters of
all time. VOL days long behind him, his output continued for a decade or two of
being on the road, putting out downloadable, low-fi, self-produced mostly
acoustic WPA series all with artwork cuffed from the old Works Projects Administration
(renamed in 1939, Bill might tell ya, as the WPA) of FDR.

Bill has always had this sense of being
rooted in the past. From songs
about the dust bowl toaudible sigh cover.jpg songs inspired by Jack Kerouac, from allusions to miners
or farmers (one great album, just for instance, is called Victory Garden) or historical incidents (“Andersonville” about the
horrific southern civil war POW camp still sometimes shows up in his live
shows) or several utterly romantic songs about the WW II-era romance of his
parents, he, more than nearly any folk/rock performer I know, can be called
rooted (even if his roots too often have him on the road; in a line on Winnowing he says “once I mistook her
for my home.”) Just look at that album cover from Audible Sigh, that historic train wreck.  

This may not be the old-timey roots
music with a lot of banjos or Appalachian fiddles, but the sound and tone and
lyrical allusions are often from other very American decades, from hardscrabble
people and places from the heartland. (The way he often says, about somebody, “kid”
or “mister,” sounds like some wiser blue-collar elder talk, doesn’t it?) Again,
think of the Steinbeck vision of Woody Guthrie, more fiery then Springsteen’s Dakota, maybe more like his Seeger


In this new record, set clearly in his
high desert home in New Mexico, Mallonee mentions horses, a pick-ax, pistols under waistcoats, a skeleton key, a boxer (who “grabs all the prize money – and a few other
things”) and somebody with “an ace of diamonds up the sleeve” which somehow
perfectly creates the feel and mood of this song cycle about being down and out,
tumbling down out West, smack in the middle of (as the second song puts it) “Those
Locust Years.”

“There’s nothing left in Oklahoma,” he
sings in “Tap Your Heart On Your Shoulder,” “on your right hand or your left/ we
took God’s good green earth and turned it into sand.” Yeah, so that’s it, a
whole lot of remorse, for the loner who has to move on, and, it seems, for the
whole cosmos which is scarred, somehow, and what approaches despair.  But yet, this song is a plea to “tap
your heart on its shoulder and see if she’s still awake.”  Listen to that line a coupla times if
you don’t have time for a spiritual retreat or money for a shrink! 

Bill’s not giving up, and in this
jaded, secular age, he is nearly an evangelist, worth more to un-churched ears
then a dozen slick worship bands with goatees and nicely torn jeans and big

The first song is sublime, and, like
nearly all of his tunes these days, insists on a lot of harsh reality, but with
glimmers of light. The song is subtitled “Out in the Cold” and that is the
theme.  It is his life, these days,
road-weary, world-weary, tired but sober, feeling under-rated, left out, yet
committed to finding hope where one can. (“No, I am not a scoffer withholding
my thanks,” he sings, believably, “My purse? It is empty but my heart overflows
its banks.”) The proper title of this wonderful opener is “Dover Beach” and is
inspired by the famous Matthew Arnold poem about the restlessness brought on as
the waves of meaning receded in the modern world.

I can show you where my heart was broke there on Dover

Truth receding like a wave/too farther out of reach

Love may bring the tide back in/hard to live, easy to


Mr. Mallonee’s raw song-writing and
passionate performance isn’t exactly depressing although he does confess much,
a practice that many of us might be well be instructed to own up to, as
well.  He sings,

Every conviction that I lived by, every truth that I was taught,

Every sermon that I sat through; well, it was all for naught.

I was always pretty bad at carryin’ my cross


Abill mallonee and murriah in concert.jpgnother slow, sad song achingly, but
yet somehow beautifully sung, offers the chorus, like a litany of confession —
“Now You Know.”  Perhaps it is more
than you want to know.  Or perhaps
it can serve as your own confession, too. 
“I can feel it all disintegrate/like paper in the flame.”  This is a line, by the way, following
an allusion to the pride of warriors – Caesar on his steed, crossing his

After speaking of the “sadness of this
place” (“Deserts speak in whispers but she rarely shows her face/ They say that
you get used to it, ah, but I’ve not found that the case”) he sings, “No matter
where I sing these songs/the devil’s always at my sleeve.” Now you know.

Speaking, literally, of the devil, one
brilliant song – for those that know his work, it almost reminds me of “Bolt
Action” or some of the louder ones from the Blister Soul-era  – is called “Got
Some Explainin’ to Do (Gotta Give the Devil His Due.)” The stanzas (without too
much gruesomeness, thankfully) highlight examples of brokenness and sin in the
world: “No matter what the disguise is, well ya gotta give the devil his due.
But whoever he is, has got some explain’ to do.”  That’s for darn sure.

He gets as preachy as he does on this CD at the end of this song,
countering the works of the devil with this cry:

Time for banishing darkness

Time for doing what is right

Time for loving the planet

Time for stepping into the light.


Winnowing isn’t
all lament and remorse, though. There is a lovely song about what I’m sure is a real tavern, somewhere
out there, called the Dew-Drop Inn. “Store-front glass & red brick, non-descript with a few old ghosts
roamin’ round.”  But there, “every
one’s yer friend and everybody’s got a story unsung.”  There’s some sad stuff there, too (“Sam’s tending bar,
brother, he’s seen it all, seen the good die young” and their the community can
realize “Some dreams get born but, most get beaten’ out /And some folks forget
how to dream at all.”) But, yet, “Stories got told and drinks were poured and
for a moment? It was Heaven here…” 

As in many of his songs, there is this
narrative of the broken and ordinary redeemed byBill and Murriah.jpg community, even if of misfits,
and then also his own personal sense of being loved. The sub-title and refrain
here is “I love you just because.” Is it sung to his wife and band partner
Murriah Rose or to the loners and oddballs hanging out at the Dew Drop?  Maybe both.

Similarly, in a beautiful, passionate
song, “In the New Dark Age” he sings — lamenting the loss of a culture of love and hope and change — “the
only lamp burning bright/is you.” Murriah? Jesus? You and me? I don’t know.  He sings the words briskly, building
the case, singing, “the game was declared over, love was escorted out, there was hardly
a shout/I’ll take the crimson & clover.” (Don’t you love that reference to
the flower-power, Tommy James hit?) Dark as it may sound, this is a rowdy, fun
song, Beatle-esque, trippy with organ and what almost sounds like backwards electronic
stuff, like it would fit on his wonderful Locket Full of Moonlight album or
VOL’s Summershine, two of my own all time favorite CDs.

He says, wrongly, I think, “in the new
dark age, no one puts up a fight.” 
Ahh, but he does, doesn’t he? — even if he will go down swinging. Mallonee’s art
testifies, bears witness to his fight. This record makes you want to join him there, makes us want
to be that light burning bright. Is it a plea to his remaining fans? An altar call?  “All the dominoes fell/we sent under a spell/and all hell.
broke. lose.” It is a lament, but also an invitation to be the light, I swear it is.

“Hall Full of Mirrors/Room Full of Woe”
sounds ominous enough, but, I’m telling you, it is an encouraging song, great
melodies, great ringing guitar riffs, evocative lyrics.  It’s one of the more upbeat tunes,
despite the use of the word “woe” — and well-produced (Bill and Murriah as the Darkling Planes play
everything) and it is splendid. The acoustic guitar at the end trails out with
chords from “All Along the Watchtower” that just seals the thing, turning it into an
anthem.  Yeah, yeah, yeah.


Several reviewers have highlighted the
gorgeous “Blame it on the Desert (Whisperin’)” which is surely one of the album’s
centerpieces.  In bouncy,
countrified boogey he sings,

What the mystic knows

What the Good Book does proclaim

You only ever own

What you give away

Blame it on the spirit

Blame it on the red wine

But then again,

Blame it on the desert whisperin’


Mr. Mallonee then sweetly sings a quick
line, “the mantra of the asphalt/road-side diner, communion table” and
reminds us of the Christ-like instruction “take only what you need/leave what
you are able.” We are naturally led
to think of the wine of Eucharist, of grace, of gospel.  Or, then again, maybe it is just the
desert whisperin’ — which the Bible itself says is God’s own Word, eh? 
(Calvin Seerveld, referring to the lines in Psalm 19 which tells us that
the creation speaks, calls it “God’s glossalia.”) Yes, Bill has heard, and
brings to us, The Word of the Lord. Thanks be to God, the God of the desert

When Bill sings “what the Good Book
does proclaim” it makes me grin, brings me a joy each time.  Not only is “the Good Book” an old,
rural colloquialism, the “does” just nails it.  Who talks like this – Abraham Lincoln? Woody Guthrie? Your
great grandma?  Yet, it isn’t
affectation.  Bill is firmly
situated in the current century – there are lines about duo-jets and
the 1%.  But he’s also “betting the
farm, babe” on some kind of old wisdom, some deep truth gleaned from his
desert, dust-bowl (locust) years. 

The last song may be an allegory, or
may serve that way – I suppose he didn’t quite mean it as such, but, then again, who knows?
The first line is, with his keen ability to create the image of a place,
about a town in Oklahoma called Dalhart.
It sounds just like dull heart.

“If I ever make it out of Dalhart/to a place where I can stand tall/a
horse would do quite nicely/but if I have to…I’m gonna crawl.” 

This is one hell of a post-modern Pilgrims Progress, from Dover Beach to
making it out of the dull heart of Dalhart.

It is the journey of many of us, I
suspect. He sings, obtusely, of what may be the “hound of heaven” (the poet’s
phrase he has used on other albums) singing  “whatever keeps tugging at your sleeve/this old flesh and
blood has gotta find a reason to believe.”  Maybe this is your experience; Something tugging at your sleeve, Christ-haunted, restless,
yet not giving up on the search. Give Winnowing repeated listens, and something will break open.  Maybe, with a little luck, even what
the mystics know, what the Good Book does proclaim.

Thank you for reading my feeble effort
to explain this artist’s gifts to us, this music that means so much to me.  Because others have said it more
eloquently and with better insight, if you’re interested, see these two excellent
reviews from Wood Between the Worlds and from Lay It Down. Both are well worth reading.

Here is one of his many interviews, describing his history with VOL, his solo work, his concerns about the commodification of art, etc etc. Worth a read if you want his take on the not so recent past.

We stock his last two similarly great, jangly, alt-country rock CDs as well, The
Power and the Glory
(2011) and Amber Waves (2012.)  Order them all from us, on sale, for
$15.00 each.  As Bill would say, “thank
you, ladies and gents.”

And, if you order all three, we will throw in as a special bonus, an old Mark Heard CD that is sure to please. Bill would dig this promo, too, I’m sure.

If you want to see his many, many downloadable projects, visit his amazing bandcamp cite, here. But buy these three from us, please! $15.00 each.

power and the glory CD Bill M.jpgamber waves CD Bill M.jpgwinnowing cover.jpg


Bill Mallonee CDs

order here
takes you to the secure Hearts & Minds order form page
just tell us what you want

inquire here
if you have questions or need more information
just ask us what you want to know

Hearts & Minds 234 East Main Street  Dallastown, PA  17313     717-246-3333